For decades, Great Harbour Cay in the Berry Islands has been a destination with tremendous natural beauty and untapped potential. Now, that may be changing.
With significant new investment planned for the island, Great Harbour Cay is entering an exciting new chapter, creating opportunities for buyers looking to get into the market before further development drives increased demand and property values.
A $35 Million Investment Could Transform the Island
In February 2026, The Tribune reported that US investor Matt O’Hayer and his company, Vital Shores LLC, received government approval to acquire the Great Harbour Cay Resort, marina and golf course for approximately $35 million.
The acquisition includes hundreds of unsold residential lots, an 80-slip marina, the island’s golf course, water utility and fuel concession, creating the potential for a significant revitalization of the destination.
While the full development plans have not yet been announced, construction and renovations are already underway, including work at the Great Harbour Cay Beach Club. Plans previously discussed by local officials have also referenced a future hotel and villas.
For an island that has experienced limited development for decades, this represents a significant potential turning point.
A Rare Opportunity on Sugar Loaf Beach
For buyers who want to position themselves ahead of growth, there are already opportunities on the island, including two adjoining beachfront lots: Lots 42 and 43, which are currently available on the island's famous 7-mile Sugar Loaf Beach and are being exclusively listed by Adama Hunt of Bahamas Realty. Together, the properties offer approximately 59,400 square feet, or more than an acre, with 100 feet of direct beach frontage on Lot 42 and a 35-foot path to the beach from Lot 43.
The properties have paved road access, nearby electricity, and are about five minutes from the renowned Sugar Beach Caves.
Their location also puts them within easy reach of Great Harbour Cay's airport, marina, golf course, restaurants, and shops.
Why Great Harbour Cay, and Why Now?
Great Harbour Cay has always had the natural appeal. What is changing is the investment and attention coming to the island.
With new development on the horizon, existing tourism infrastructure, beautiful beaches, and some of the best boating and fishing in The Bahamas, Great Harbour Cay is becoming an island to watch.
For buyers with a long-term perspective, this could be an opportunity to get into the market while the island is still relatively undeveloped and before its next chapter is fully established.
The Bahamas has many beautiful islands, but Great Harbour Cay offers something different: the opportunity to be part of a destination that may be just getting started.
The Bigger Picture
Great Harbour Cay’s story extends beyond individual property acquisitions. New investment, tourism initiatives, and infrastructure improvements could help transform the island into a more active destination, creating opportunities for homeowners, businesses, and investors.
While development takes time and future appreciation is never guaranteed, Great Harbour Cay’s natural assets and emerging investment make it a destination worth watching.
Explore available properties in Great Harbour Cay or contact Bahamas Realty to learn more about opportunities in the Berry Islands.
Footer Social